Over the course of the last few weeks, I’ve spent time visiting incoming freshmen and their families in their homes. During these visits, I ask teens to reflect on their experience in our junior high ministry. I also share information about our high school ministry with them. As part of this, I ask parents, “What’s one thing you’d change about our junior high ministry?” In answer to this question, parents of boys typically tell me:
“It wouldn’t hurt to put the boys and girls together sometimes.”
This statement is a critique of our small group ministry, which in junior high we separate by gender. When asked, parents will typically elaborate on this critique, saying something about how “It’d help to control the boys if they were around the girls.”
Truthfully, it’s the last part of this critique that’s hard for me to swallow. The point of junior high small groups isn’t control. It’s relational development and faith formation.
In fact, that’s why we switched to same-gendered small groups several years ago. This separation is one that I wholeheartedly believe in, for three main reasons:
1. Junior high boys and girls are different. At this age, dividing teens by gender enables you to structure small groups somewhat differently. Boy groups can be more activity driven, and girl groups, more conversation driven. Without the other gender present, both guys and girls have the freedom to say things they wouldn’t necessarily express around someone of the opposite gender.
2. Developmentally, dividing junior high students by genders makes sense because they tend to understand their identity first in same-gendered contexts. In other words, for junior high students, identity exploration is safest in same-gendered contexts. Since identity development is one of the primary sociological tasks during this phase of development, it makes sense that we try to capitalize on this with same-gendered small groups.
3. Since same-gendered small groups allow you to structure them differently in order to give teens a safe place for identity exploration, their natural by-product is relationships. When junior high students leave small groups having formed friendships with one another, their entire group is much more likely to transition into your high school ministry together.
When it comes to the identity development and faith formation of teens, junior high same-gendered small groups make sense. I know this because over the last several years, we’ve consistently reaped the fruit of them. Teens are entering our high school ministry with deeper relationships than ever before.
That’s why, even though I hear such feedback regularly, I’m committed to same-gendered junior high small groups… And to educating parents about why they’re important.
After all, when parents realize the why behind the what typically, their understanding of our ministry increases. So, too, does their confidence and trust in our ministry, something that is good for everyone.
I feel every second or third week can you mix of boys and girls is beneficial. Girls being females bring different opinions and ideas. Also them being deeper thinkers than boys also adds more. If we are grooming these young people to be good adults, leaders, and carry the word of God they will be doing that in adult life together as male and female husband and wife.
Between the ages of 15 and 18 I attended a youth group at my Mom’s church which was a run-of-the-mill evangelical non-denominational church. I completely disagree with this take. There is no good reason to separate boys from girls at this age, or any age, also it is not biblical. Separating boys from girls at this age makes them less likely to see each other as equals which is important for young people growing into adults. Sure, young boys and young girls may have differences in the ways that they express themselves, and in the ways that they interact, and that is all the more reason to encourage them to interact with each-other. Diverse ways of thinking lead to unique and often enlightening conversations. At my youth group we were always separated at the beginning and split into gendered groups. We would have a study session separately and then after the boys and girls were allowed to play together. That being said, whenever we got back together, no one talked about what the other group had discussed. It was super weird, and it made it really uncomfortable to even engage with the other group. Usually when we played, even though we were in the same gym together, we did not play together or really talk to each other at all. It was really unhealthy and the connection between the girls and the boys was damaged significantly by it. On top of that, there was a culture of boys being better than girls and the fact that we were separated made the issue even more severe. A lot of the boys would make fun of the girls and pick on them for being girls. They would also make fun of them for the things they were interested in and the stuff they talked about. The whole vibe was super weird, and the separation of the genders made it so much worse. Dividing groups of people in church makes no real sense. Yes, girls and boys are different, men and women are different, that doesn’t mean we should be separate. To say that young people understand their identity “first” in same-gendered contexts doesn’t support the conclusion that we should separate by gender. They may be more inclined to share personal details in a same-gender group, but they should be encouraged to do the same in a mixed-gender group. That’s the whole point of having youth leadership. Lastly, the claim that a same-gender group is more likely to move into the ministry is not backed by any evidence aside from your own anecdotal evidence. This is a really weak claim. The downsides of separating youth groups by gender which include the development of sexism in youths, internalizing of inequality, creating a spiritual divide between the genders, and causing conflict between genders is not worth any of the supposed upsides that you brought up here. They should be encouraged to grow in the faith together. Men and Women live lives together in secular culture so it makes no sense to create division between them in church. It should be the place where the genders can discuss spiritual issues across the gender divide.